Friday, September 18, 2015

Now here's something I can really disagree with: Criticism of the Obama Papal Guest List.

"We need not respond to every 'seeming' outrage ..."
But we just did.

So who should he have invited?

Steven Colbert?  Haha!  Just kidding - can't stand the guy.  What?  He's so not funny.

As it is he will be surrounded by faithful Catholics, so who cares who will be at the White House?

Anyway, Elizabeth Scalia pretty much accuses (soon-to-be-Catholic-convert) President Obama of playing a dirty trick on Pope Francis and inviting Catholic dissenters and other religious riff-raff to the White House to greet the Pope.  "Packing the list with open dissenters to church teaching, though, is a purposeful, planned and deliberate rebuke to the church."

Elizabeth's op-ed calls out Obama and company for courting controversy, suggesting Obama is intent upon riling up Catholic conservatives?  Sounds like it to me:
But the game is not actually about challenging the pope: it’s about keeping the culture wars flaming and political divisions alive; it’s about manipulating the angry right into pitching a fit because the pope didn’t pivot away from Obama’s guests, shouting “Arrepentirse! Repent!”; it’s about cueing the angry left to cry, “Shame! See how these
hateful Christians shove one another!” while the press shuffles forward chanting that Francis is, “one of us; one of us!” - Obama's Game
You think?

Personally, I think Obama and troupe really believe these are people Pope Francis wants to hear from, as well as should hear from.  Obama has many Catholic friends who would have helped out with the guest list - many vying for the first places at table and front row seats in the audience.  Is he really trying to stick it to anyone?  Does it matter?  The Pope is going to be whisked all over the East Coast, meeting lots of people - is it all a set up?  On some level it is - the Pope is going to meet handpicked guests at every event.  It is what it is.   He'll also welcome people who weren't invited, I'm sure.

Did St. Matthew deliberately assemble only prostitutes and tax-collectors and sleazy politicos and sinners to dinner after Christ called him?  (Mt.9:10)  He must have been trying to provoke the Pharisees, huh?  Or did they just show up?

Just having fun here.  Elizabeth was too - I hope.  As she states at the end of her essay:
This manipulation is such a predictable (and really tiresome) game, it’s surprising how few people have fun with it, or simply laugh at it, which — in truth — is always the best response to stage managers and deluded illusionists. - Obama's Game

Bloggers are going to keep repeating stories like this for the next couple of weeks.

What?  She said to have fun with it.

Song for this post here.


  1. This comment has been removed by the author.

  2. Typo and too much cattiness in deleted comment. ;p

    But I stand by this:

    Papa Francis, being the caballero that he is, will be gracious and open and radiate Christ our Lord. Many will step into that radiance of the Risen Lord and be transformed while others will continue to run away and deny the truth of who Christ is.
    Some may be pierced to the heart, some may smirk, some will come away convinced our Holy Father will change Church teaching "so that all will fit in."

    May our Holy Father be heard, listened to, reflected upon and may his witness to who Christ is inspire the rest of us. Mama Mary will be journeying with her little Mijo so I know she will be with us like always. ^^

    1. Yaya - that was beautiful and every word is true!

  3. He's going to meet Mary Jo Copeland. I read an article in which the Vatican objected to the guest list as it's inappropriate. No idea if it will change. Papa will be kind to all and will bring Christ to these people.


Please comment with charity and avoid ad hominem attacks. I exercise the right to delete comments I find inappropriate. If you use your real name there is a better chance your comment will stay put.