Showing posts with label I get so sick of this gay bullshit. Show all posts
Showing posts with label I get so sick of this gay bullshit. Show all posts

Friday, September 01, 2017

One last post on Joseph Sciambra and Fr. James Martin, S.J.



[Ed.Note: I first posted this on Facebook, then took it down, my Facebook page is not followed by very many people, and few seem to care about stuff like this.  In addition, a Cardinal Sarah letter just broke in the WSJ, pretty much taking down Fr. Martin's book.  Monsignor Pope and others on Facebook are applauding the letter, which should settle any dispute with Fr. Martin's POV for most Catholics.  Likewise, Joseph Sciambra is indeed getting the recognition and kudos he needs with a Church Militant spot covering his interview of Paprocki.  Therefore, it seems to me the increased coverage means Joseph Sciambra no longer needs to be concerned that he is being ignored by the 'Catholic left'.] 

"What I am not willing to suffer I ought by all means to shun." - Imitation of Christ

Joseph Sciambra is taking flak on Facebook for his criticism of Fr. James Martin. He has many criticizing him in return. Sciambra is a good man, from a very complex background, and his conversion story is quite remarkable. His apostolate even more remarkable, as it includes evangelizing right in the middle of the Castro - so to speak. His story is pretty extraordinary. Nevertheless, his complaint that Catholic spokesmen for LGBTQ issues working towards some kind of dialogue, albeit ignoring his story and work, just might verge a little on the self-indulgent. Joseph Sciambra has his own forum, a website and he is fairly often interviewed on radio and podcasts, as well as featured in online magazine articles.

Catholics unacquainted with pastoral care of homosexual persons may not know that the only approved apostolate in the Church is Courage - it's a national group with diocesan chapters guided by a priest, established to help gay/same-sex-attracted people live a chaste, celibate life in accord with Catholic teaching. Writers like Fr. Martin already know it exists and is fully approved, has a strong following and so on. Though I'm not aware of Joe being invited to speak at a major Courage conference, his message and life is certainly a good model for the group. In other words, I'm trying to point out that individuals like Joseph do indeed have a voice and their stories are indeed recognized - in the Church and in and through a venue such as Courage.

Catholics, such as Fr. Martin appear to be reaching out to those who are not yet reconciled with Catholic teaching, and or misunderstand what the Church teaches and even reject it. One may agree or disagree on how he does that, what he says in his books, and so on. Just as many may disagree with Joe. Social media is like open-mike night - if one condemns another, the other should expect return fire. 

As the Imitation counsels: "What I am not willing to suffer I ought by all means to shun."


Sciambra's Facebook post I responded to:
Joseph Sciambra - 8/31/17 3 hrs · I find it amazing how the gay Catholic Left and their allies bemoan certain members of the hierarchy for judging homosexuality without ever (they claim) knowing someone from the LGBT community – the main point that James Martin keeps making is that the Church must start by “listening to the stories that L.G.B.T. Catholics have to tell of rejection and humiliation by society and by the church…” But then these same teary-eyed hand wringing virtue signaling advocates turn around and marginalize me – Hypocrites. They want an open forum - for themselves.

I still think he needs to beware the temptation to celebrity.



Addendum:  Once again, it appears I made a mistake in judgment.  It is good to be corrected, and especially so by Mr. Sciambra.  Joseph explained to me what he means when he speaks of his message and outreach being marginalized, and or ignored.  Explaining that in San Francisco, just about every parish with a sizable LGBT presence is frequently subject to the influence of the so-called 'gay-mafia'.  Hence Sciambra is either barred from speaking, or as in one case a speaking engagement was cancelled due to protests.  That's what he meant when he says he is marginalized.  He is not looking any sort of national spotlight.  I apologize I suggested that might have been his intention, it is not.

That said, many are mystified, as is Joseph, as to why the huge blow-back against his outreach, as well as Bishop Paprocki's statements on pastoral care for homosexual persons, not to mention the sometimes hostile remarks made against priests like Fr. Martin.  I think it's because, though their statements are very clear concerning Catholic teaching and are necessary to dispel error,  their statements and POV is sometimes sensationalized on social media and especially in conservative media, which happens to be the only source willing and able to publish their statements, and or stories.  In doing that, the stories are often editorialized and inflamed against those whose approach to the subject is deemed too liberal or conciliatory, and so on.  Therefore their LGBTQ opponents politicize the message, which means they connect Catholicism with the 'alt-right'.  It's happened throughout history, perhaps most notably in Franco's Spain.  Very simply, so-called 'liberals' turned 'leftists' want to silence anyone who opposes a more liberal agenda.  It's a form of censorship not unlike the new iconoclast movement employed to tear down historical monuments and so on.

Anyway - I will ty to be more careful when discussing these matters in the future.  Again, my apologies to Joseph Sciambra.  

Tuesday, August 29, 2017

Outing


[Ed. Note: I heard from Joe Sciambra, he was not attempting to 'out' Fr. Martin at all, he simply copied and pasted the story from The Bay Area Reporter interview with Martin – he did that with the title of the blog post which came right from the interview.  Joseph said if people want to take issue with the article, they should go after The Bay Area Guardian. Sciambra offered no personal commentary in the blog post, nor did he intend it to be an outing.  My apologies for believing that was his intention.]


'Most of the vicious stuff has been from the far right.' - Fr. James Martin

Last night Scott Eric Alt posted a link on Facebook regarding Joe Sciambra's blog post "James Martin prefers not to make public his own sexuality."

I was annoyed and spontaneously posted a critical comment, which I removed after Melinda Selmys graciously posted a rather sympathetic comment regarding Sciambra and why he might do a post most readers consider an attempt to out Fr. Martin.

Why do people want to out others?

In Fr. Martin's case, I believe it may be connected to the 'gay-lobby' theory of gays infiltrating the Catholic Church.  I think they believe if they can reveal Martin's sexuality - sexual preference - sexual inclination - whatever they want people to call it, they can somehow prove he is trying to undermine Catholic teaching and is part of the 'gay-lobby' intent upon doing so.

Likewise, when a priest 'comes out' - credibility is shot.  Orthodoxy is questioned.  How?  By the mere fact he would dare identify as gay or homosexual.  Even if he said he had SSA - doubts would pop up.  Is he celibate?  Is he chaste?  Does he like young men and boys?  What if ...?  See how that works?

Last night I said gays like to out people - frequently, even SSA Catholics do - at least in my experience.  Politically, revealing the sexuality of otherwise closeted people helps to demonstrate that even upstanding, well respected, accomplished individuals can be and are gay.  The more people out, the more acceptable society needs to be.  Ex-gays, SSA Catholics can also want to out people for various reasons.  They don't want to be left behind, ignored, or missed?  I don't know?  They want to be acknowledged for their fidelity to Catholic teaching?  Perhaps there is a vindictive motivation?  I'm not sure.

When I first began blogging a gay Catholic reader and a Courage member, told me that another popular blogger with whom he corresponded wanted to know if I was 'one of them' - and the consensus was 'yep - he's one of us'.  Whenever I wrote about chastity or gay issues, I had comments that I was gay, in the closet, this or that, and that if I was honest - I'd reveal all of that to readers.  Gay activists and gay Catholics wanted me 'outed' - and of course straight readers wanted me outed as well.  I laughed because I thought, well, if it's so obvious, why should I say anything at all?  It's no ones business.

They lay up heavy burdens hard to carry.

Nevertheless, it still amazes me, especially since many Catholics love to bang the theologically correct rules over the heads of anyone who uses LGBTQ terminology or dares to say 'I'm gay - but celibate' - in other words, they live a chaste life in obedience to Catholic teaching.  Yeah but!  You can't say gay, you can't be gay and Catholic.  Then, you can't have gay friends.  Once Fr. Z asked, "Why would anyone want gay friends?"  There seems to be an entirely occult list of protocols one needs to adhere to in order to be a good Catholic suffering from same sex attraction.  The language on both sides of this coin is so convoluted and dissociative, it's frustrating as hell.  Who wants that sort of identity in the first place?  Why would you even tell anyone you have same sex attraction - like it's a disease - what does that even mean to anyone outside the confessional?  I certainly do not suffer from same sex attraction - I've suffered temptations against chastity, but attractive people do not in anyway cause me to suffer.

The Church proclaims that she cannot be so callous as to identify someone by their sexual preferences, inclination, or attraction.  Therefore, these religious folk who want to out everyone else should be ashamed of themselves.  In a strange way, they actually contradict the Catholic teaching they lay on the backs of others when they insist someone should “make public his own sexuality.”

That said, I admire Fr. Martin, who like Pope Francis respects the person who chooses to identify in the way they experience themselves to be.  To accept people where they are at - right now - in the present moment.  I disagree with Fr. Martin on several points, I don't believe people are necessarily 'born that way', and I believe chastity is necessary in gay friendship/partnership, and so on.  I also would never endorse New Ways Ministry.  Yet Fr. Martin's sexuality should not be an issue here, he is a Jesuit priest, celibate and vowed to chastity.

The stigma of being gay friendly.

There is a long standing problem with this entire project of outing a priest - it's a contradiction.  When I was working to have a Courage group formed in my diocese, Fr. Harvey wrote a letter to the Archbishop, I asked numerous priests to help - no one would touch it.  "You are on your own Terry." In the 1980's, and probably today, any priest who ministers to gay people is immediately suspect, or at least considered 'gay friendly'.  Even when it involves Courage, no one would touch it unless they were assigned by the local ordinary - otherwise there might be talk - that was the stigma attached.

These types of posts by Sciambra and others are not helpful to anyone.  It quickly feeds the gossip mill and may come close to detraction - and borders on slander.  No matter how deeply we are hurt, or have been hurt through abuse or sexual degradation, we have no right to impugn the character of another.  With all due respect to Joe Sciambra, he needs to be careful not to allow himself be exploited by those religious people who use his testimony indiscreetly.  Likewise, he needs to be more discreet in his apostolate and the repetition of his pre-conversion story, which others seem to love to sensationalize.  He's a good man, no doubt, and his message is important.  He needs to beware the temptation to celebrity.

Interestingly, on the post I referred to from last night, he was more or less attacked and criticized rather severely.  One commenter dismissed him as a 'minor blogger' while others said, 'who is Joseph Sciambra' - all little ways of diminishing him, of discounting his credibility, while reducing his person to a sort of caricature.  Melinda Selmys pointed that out in her commentary, which was removed when the thread was deleted by the originator of the discussion.

This isn't really a huge issue for me any longer.  Although I can get myself pulled into a discussion, I don't think it's as important as I used to.   People need time and maturity - and faith - to work things out.  The key is perseverance.  Don't be afraid.  So many people online are afraid and they strike fear in others.  Don't be afraid.


Saturday, June 11, 2016

More things I don't get ...

Freudian pastoral care.


Homo-nuts.

I watched a bit of Fr. Pacwa interviewing the author Robert Reilly whose new book 'draws from from his extensive knowledge of classic political philosophy to outline the full scope of dangers in modern homosexual culture.'
Robert Reilly was Senior Advisor for Information Strategy (2002-2006) for the US Secretary of Defense, after which he taught at National Defense University. He was the director of the Voice of America (2001-2002) and served in the White House as a Special Assistant to the President (1983-1985). A graduate of Georgetown University and the Claremont Graduate University, he writes widely on "war of ideas" issues, foreign policy, and classical music.
Reilly wrote a very informative book titled: Making Gay Okay: How Rationalizing Homosexual Behavior Is Changing Everything.   I didn't read it when it first came out, just excerpts, but I found nothing wrong with the content.  His appearance on EWTN Live was an interview focused upon the newer, revised edition from Ignatius, sporting a new cover.  (Meant to contrast the incredible change in lgbtq politics from the Reagan White House to the Obama White House.)




When I tuned in Reilly was discussing the American Psychiatric Association removing homosexuality from the DSM, saying it was no longer a mental illness.  Most of my readers know all about that and most also understand it remains a controversial topic.  I turned TV off since I was busy in the garden, and I'm not all that interested in gay stuff anymore.  Nevertheless, I was distracted by what I heard.  Fr. Pacwa was very interested in what Reilly had to say and seemed to be delving into the psychiatric issues.

I understand that priests and spiritual directors are interested in the psychological issues involving homosexuality, yet as the Catechism states, "Its psychological genesis remains largely unexplained. Basing itself on Sacred Scripture, which presents homosexual acts as acts of grave depravity" - thus homosexual acts are intrinsically disordered and contrary to natural law and immoral.   Yet the Church acknowledges its 'psychological genesis remains largely unexplained' and addresses it as a moral disorder.  Therefore, on some level it seems to me the psychological diagnosis is not all that important in pastoral care - nor is pastoral an exercise in conversion therapy - making gay people straight.  The Church never says that.  Likewise, the sacrament of penance - confession - is not to be confused with therapy or psychological analysis.

Of course there is nothing wrong about studying its psychological genesis, especially to understand the homosexual person - but to base pastoral care upon its psychological genesis seems to create a huge obstacle for persons who experience homosexual tendencies.  In other words, does that mean they are nuts?

See, that's what gay people think we mean by using that diagnosis.  I know many successful gay people who have stable relationships - though immoral as regards Church teaching.  Yet they have careers, live quiet lives, in some cases, raise families; many are active in the community, some are in politics, others in ministry - yep - priests.  Are they nuts?  Do they need to be segregated, labeled or diagnosed and stigmatized?  If you examine the lives of homosexual individuals perhaps some have problems - depression, bi-polar, emotional issues similar to straight people.  But are they meant to be in a psychological category all by themselves?  Is there a special medication for it?  If you say you have SSA - same sex attraction, but don't act out, does that mean you're totally sane?

I know a guy who tells gay guys he has SSA all of the time?  Is it empathy?  Disinterestedness to talk like that?  Does it mean he's no longer nuts but wants to help the crazy gay guys he meets?

Which makes me wonder about the ex-gays.  Are they no longer nuts?  Because they renounce homosexual acts and behavior, because they get married, are they suddenly no longer nuts?  I know some ex-gays who are pretty nuts and inordinately focused upon all things homosexual - but they are no longer gay and therefore no longer nuts and everything they say is to be believed because they are no longer nuts.

Get it?

I don't.

Early treatment for hysteria in women.


One more for the road ...

Then there is the case of the transgender woman teaching in Catholic school in San Francisco - approved by Archbishop Cordileone.  (Never forget that Cardinal Burke - as Bishop - gave permission for a transgender woman to be a diocesan religious sister.)

So.  Talk about nuts.  There have been people condemned for coming out as gay - even losing their jobs in Catholic schools and institutions - but transgender is okay under special circumstances?

I'm against it.

Designating homos and trans - the entire spectrum of LGBTQ as mentally ill helps anti-gay people - but does nothing to dissuade persons with these inclinations to 'change' their orientation or their behavior.  Dropping statistical facts on how unhealthy and screwed up the lifestyle can be does nothing to dissuade persons from being 'gay'.

Pope Francis not only speaks about the need to 'discern' but also to 'accompany' and help to 'integrate' those who fall short of Christian wholeness-holiness.  I'm not sure how that works, but I don't think pushing the mental illness diagnosis, or death threats from natural causes work all that well.






Saturday, October 03, 2015

Confirmed. Homos in the Vatican: Polish priest fired from the CDF after he publicly comes out as "gay"...

Monsignor Krzystof Charamsa
(He just thinks he's gay.)


True story.

I'm a little surprised because I didn't think Polish priests could be gay.  (I wonder if he had said he was same-sex-attracted things would have been different?)  Turns out this priest also has a partner he fell in love with. That's hard to understand considering priests and religious are expected to live chaste, celibate lives.  How do you say Mass while living a double life?  That's got to be difficult.  After reading more, turns out the priest understood he would have to leave the priesthood, but not before making a 'mess'.  It appears he was hoping to influence the Church to change it's teaching on homosexuality.  Possibly giving credence to several conspiracy theories of homosexuals exerting undo influence upon the Synod, not to mention the CDF.
VATICAN CITY (Reuters) - The Vatican dismissed a priest from his post in a Holy See office on Saturday after he told a newspaper he was gay and urged the Catholic Church to change its stance on homosexuality. 
Monsignor Krzystof Charamsa was removed from his position at the Congregation of the Doctrine of the Faith, the Vatican's doctrinal arm where he had worked since 2003, a statement said. 
Charamsa, 43, and a Polish theologian, announced he was gay and had a partner in a long interview with Italy's Corriere della Sera newspaper on Saturday. 
He later held a news conference with his partner, a Spanish man, and gay activists at a Rome restaurant. They had planned a demonstration in front of the Vatican but changed the venue several hours before it was due to have started.

The Vatican said Charamsa's dismissal had nothing to do with his comments on his personal situation, which it said "merit respect". 
But it said giving the interview and the planned demonstration was "grave and irresponsible" given their timing on the eve of a synod of bishops who will discuss family issues, including how to reach out to gays. 
It said his actions would subject the synod, which Pope Francis is due to open on Sunday, to "undue media pressure". 
The issue of homosexuality and the Church has dominated the aftermath of the pope's visit to the United States last week. 
In Saturday's interview, Charamsa said his partner had helped him come to terms with his sexuality and knew he would have to give up the priesthood, although the Vatican statement made no reference to this outcome. 
"It's time for the Church to open its eyes about gay Catholics and to understand that the solution it proposes to them -- total abstinence from a life of love -- is inhuman," he was quoted as saying. 
The Catholic Church teaches that homosexuality is not a sin but that homosexual acts are. - Source

It's always something, huh?

I'm not really surprised, I guess.  Although the timing appears to be a calculated move - to embarrass and to exert pressure upon the upcoming Synod?  A somewhat underhanded attempt perhaps.

Obviously this sort of 'behavior' within the curia, or 'papal court', as well as chanceries, has existed for centuries.  Doesn't make it easier though.


Another reminder why Little Therese prayed so much for priests.


. . .

They look like decent guys.



Post script: The Monsignor is in his mid-forties.  His friend appears to be about the same age - there goes another theory, I suppose.  So what happened?  How did they meet?  Did he go out to bars which cater to the same-sex-attracted?  Did he have a circle of same-sex-attracted friends he was inordinately interested in?  Was he suffering from SSA?  Was he sexually abused as a kid?  Did he get into porn?  Were bathrobes required in seminary?  Is he really into fashion, dance-trans, opulent lifestyle?  So many questions - facetious and serious.


I hope and pray for their salvation.  New guys to add to my prayer list.


*PSS: Central casting:  Bradley Cooper and Ben Affleck should portray these guys if Barb Nicolosi and Act One ever get into film production.  What?



Tuesday, September 29, 2015

You can't condemn Eve Tushnet and Ron Belgau who simply seek to befriend gay people and then go to the Folsom Street Fair for photo ops like you are Mother Teresa.


I apologize in advance for this, but ...


Really?  So Tushnet goes to a church that welcomes gay people no 
matter where they are at in their conversion process.  They identify as gay.
  What's the difference here?

Ed. note:  I've edited - added commentary in red italics for greater clarity.
I also clarified points in the comment section.


C'mon. - (In the Second Reading Sunday - the Apostle wrote, "Come now ..." - C'mon is like that in tone.)

You can't say gay but you can say 'Jesus loves gay men'? - (You just did.  Your t-shirt said gay - you said, Jesus loves gay men.)

Yeah, he does - Jesus does love gay men.  But will you please knock it off?  Please? - (That is - knock off making an issue out of people using the term gay.)

You never met a gay man?  Really?  Who are you talking to and posing with in these photos? - (Joe wrote a post titled, 'I never met a gay man'.  - I think he did.)

Gay people like to pretend. - (They say, don't say gay - say SSA - until they are in that milieu.  It's dishonest.)

Don't keep pretending... gay people are never going to get beyond this phony conflict if we don't stop pretending.

Let me tell you ...

I love you Joey Sciambra. - (But give people a break and stop lecturing them about 'how' they 'accompany' others in their journey.)

Seriously, you are a good man doing good things - but as Christ told the disciples in the Gospel, 'Whoever is not against us is for us.'

Seek to please God - not men. - (So many critics try to put obstacles in the way of those who want to share the joy of the Gospel - last weekend the Pope reminded us how Jesus “keeps telling his disciples to go, to go out. He urges them to go out and meet others where they really are, not where we think they should be.")


PS: Joe Sciambra is doing that in his own peculiar fashion - nothing wrong with that.  However, it seems to me Catholics associated with Spiritual Friendship are doing the same thing - so I'm having trouble understanding all the opposition from Joe on this topic.  It strikes me as a bit disingenuous.

That's all.



Thursday, January 15, 2015

Get. Out.




I wonder what brought this on?

Actually, it was the Irish priest who outed himself from the pulpit last weekend.  I mentioned it here.

What was the statistic Jeannine Gramick cited?  40%-50% of priests are gay?  And she and a whole bunch of others think they should all come out.  That doesn't mean they are sexually active - I hope - but either way, if they all Got. Out. who would be left?  What would be left?

I sometimes wrote on how homosexuals weren't supposed to be admitted to seminary or religious life, but despite the rules, they have been admitted and most likely continue to be admitted.  I have no control over that ...  Then there are so many questions.  What if they used to be gay but are now just SSA?  What if they were notoriously gay - but now just have another job that keeps them busy after parish office hours?  What if they are gay and celibate - like gay-Catholics - and the actually say gay?  Then Michael brings up the fact there are gay bishops and gay friendly bishops - then what do you do?  What if you want to report a suspicious priest?  Or request that a Courage chapter be established in the archdiocese and he won't let you because he's against it?  What to do?

What to do Michael Voris?

I just want to be able to receive the sacraments and go to Mass - oh - and when I'm dying, please call a priest.  Make sure it's not a woman though.

If it's not one thing it's another, isn't it?






Monday, May 12, 2014

Kissing the hands of the unclean ...



For saints have hands that pilgrims' hands do touch, 
   And palm to palm is holy palmers' kiss.


This past weekend I encountered something online that kind of troubled me.  One was a photo of the Holy Father kissing the hand of a priest who was described as a homosexual activist.  He is known for his good works as well, and Pope Francis obviously holds him in great esteem - or at least respect for his priesthood.  It's long been a Catholic tradition to kiss the hands of priests - because they are consecrated.

Likewise St. Francis made a show of kneeling before a wayward priest to show his respect - to demonstrate the reverence due to Christ in front of the townsfolk who were scandalized by the priest's lifestyle.  Some say the priest lived openly with a woman - others suggest he may have held heretical views.  Francis showed him reverence and respect, and the priest changed his life.

It is good to recall that St. Teresa of Avila confessed to a priest who was also involved in a sinful life - indeed they became friends and she frequented his confessional.  Her fondness never became dangerous, although she voiced those concerns.  Ultimately she was instrumental in obtaining the priests conversion and he broke off a relationship he had with a woman.  Teresa went away and soon learned that the priest died a holy death.  What if - rather than befriending him - she had scorned him?

All things considered, I'm not sure there is the slightest reason for Catholics to be scandalized that Pope Francis kisses the hands of a priest, a leper, a Muslim, a homosexual, or the hands of Jesus Christ.

Don't forget St. John Paul kissed a Koran.

Pope Benedict gave communion to Brother Roger of Taize.

Popes do stuff we may not always understand - but surely Francis kissing the hand of Don Michele de Paolis cannot be a scandal.

I un-Friend you then.

"That's not how it works - that's not how any of this works."  That's a line from my favorite commercial - you have to watch it if you don't watch TV - and you live online.

An online acquaintance sent me an email this past weekend.  Evidently he received a 'friend request' from someone we know on Facebook.  The guy refused the friend request ...  for reasons which kinda-sorta seem to tie in somewhat with the criticism leveled against the Pope for kissing the activist priest's hand.

Before I go on, just let me point out that one's membership or participation on Google, Facebook, and other social media sites such as LinkedIn automatically generate 'friend requests' without our knowledge.  I've had many requests and at first, in some cases, I responded sending personal emails explaining I'm no longer on Facebook, or though I'm on Linkedin, I am not active.  The blog is more than enough exposure for me.  Long story short, the recipients responded that they never sent a request - it is either our personal computer or the sites we belong to which recognize links/cookies what have you, and automatically generate the requests.  So how does one respond when one receives a friend request?  I don't.

Having said that - a legitimate friend request should be a personal thing - between you and the person who wants to friend you.  If you don't want to be-friend them - don't acknowledge - unless you have something to say - yet as I said - it should be between the two of you.  Unless you want to write an 'open letter' to them and get a link on some Catholic portal for being a defender of the faith.

I don't know either of these people personally - we've never met.  So what is an online friendship?  How can it exist without personal interaction?  That's another post - in fact I've written about this stuff before.  I've had online 'friends' I never ever heard from again.  I'm also un-friended or have people drop me in their links for whatever reason - and believe me when I tell you, more than likely I never knew you were there in the first place.  Is that 'friendship'?  Can I trust you'll be there for me when I need you?

The point here is that I don't need to be apprised of any ones personal rebuke of another person.  When you share your personal communication to another person with me, how do you expect me to trust you to keep confidence with me or anyone else?

I can't trust people who do such things.  I don't trust people who make contact with others in order to report back to someone else what is going on in the other person's life.  There is something dishonest about that.


Fraternal correction.

Years ago I had a friend who insisted 'we' write a letter to a friend who happened to be the sister of my sister-in-law.  Her fiance had been waiting for an annulment, but the two decided to get married right away - before the annulment came through.  My friend - a former seminarian objected and warned they would be sinning.  The couple knew all of this but decided to marry anyway.  My friend said it was incumbent upon me - it was my duty as a Catholic to pen a letter declaring that we would not attend the wedding - since we could not witness an invalid marriage.  Fine.  I wasn't even going to be in town when the wedding took place, and chances are I would have quietly avoided the wedding anyway.  I don't like going to weddings or funerals.

Long story short, my friend had a letter all prepared, had me sign it and sent it along.  The censure simply added to the dysfunction already blazing with my friends, the in-laws and my brother.  The wedding took place, the couple eventually had the marriage blessed, although truth be told, it is questionable the marriage was ever consummated - don't ask.

My self-righteous friend eventually left the Church and joined a Protestant sect and has led a rather curious life himself.

What's my point?  Not sure.

No man can be trusted - all have left the right path.

All things re-considered here, if, in your practice of Christian charity and evangelization you want to blow people out of the water - just be careful.  As St. Paul said, 'If you think you are standing - watch out, lest you fall."
Now it is of course required of stewards that they be found trustworthy. It does not concern me in the least that I be judged by you or any human tribunal; I do not even pass judgment on myself; I am not conscious of anything against me, but I do not thereby stand acquitted; the one who judges me is the Lord. Therefore, do not make any judgment before the appointed time, until the Lord comes, for he will bring to light what is hidden in darkness and will manifest the motives of our hearts, and then everyone will receive praise from God. - 1 Corinthians 4
I am, on the other hand, very much aware of my failings and shortcomings.  I am a weak man.  I cannot even trust myself.  Indeed, I trust very few people, precisely because of stories like these, and other situations of betrayal and denial I write about.  Yet as I said, most especially I do not trust myself - I like to repeat the prayer of St. Philip Neri from time to time, "Lord, I want to love you, but you know you can't trust me!"  Therefore, how could I rebuff someone who might extend his hand in friendship?

Over the years I've received sharp criticism from Courage members, gay-Catholics, as well as from people who despise gay people - because they believe I am 'soft' on people who are so-called gay-activists or who simply do not accept Catholic teaching.  What can I say? Who am I to rebuke or condemn?  I always pray for forgiveness and hope our Lord will have mercy upon my weakness.  I'm not better than anyone.

Monday, February 10, 2014

Johnny Weir-d



Johnny Weir is an NBC Commentator at the Olympics.

He's getting people riled up too.  Fr. Z is disgusted - which almost makes it even funnier - but for me, it's just queer.  Really queer.

Weir is protesting Holy Russia's policy against GLBTQ propaganda and the rough treatment shown to gay protesters.  How?  By simply showing up ... making some sort of fashion statement.  I wonder if Lady Gaga is his fashion consultant?
Weir has appeared with full makeup -- blush, lipstick, etc. -- as well as silk blouses and gaudy jewelry. Hairstyles have ranged form piled on top to a braided tiara. This was his plan from the beginning, as NJ.com reports:
[My wardrobe will be a] cross between Coco Chanel and Brooks Brothers” with a hint of “Stanley Tucci’s character in the Hunger Games without the blue hair.
Weir says the games are not supposed to be about politics.
The Olympics are supposed to be about these wonderful athletes who are chasing these lifelong dreams, not politics.
Weir just made it all about politics.
Photo credit.  I think he's looking more Lily Tomlin than Coco Chanel.

Saturday, January 25, 2014

Chasing my tail



Getting sucked into the debate over the New Homophiles.

It's getting deep and way over my head - the arguments which show up in the com boxes at Crisis on the subject of concern over the new homophiles.  Last weekend I was invited to comment on Austin Ruse's post, which included a mention of my posts on the group, and I've been distracted ever since.  The arguments in the com box at Crisis remind me of a cat chasing her tail.  They wear me down, distract me, confuse me - that's what I mean by making my head swim and chasing my tail.

The arguments are getting to be like the Chris West controversy over his interpretation of Theology of the Body.  It tends to be more an academic-intellectual debate playing magisterial and non-magisterial teaching against each other rather than fostering any deeper understanding.  The so-called new homophiles usually speak over the heads of the ordinary person.  They claim to be leaving Catholic teaching intact, yet it nearly always sounds foreign to the common understanding Catholics have of traditional moral teaching.  They use self-referential gay vernacular in their literature,  explaining how faithful they are to Catholic teaching while dismissing what they consider offensive or hard to understand language used in Magisterial instructions.  A fact more than ironic, since Magisterial-catechetical teaching is always clearly stated and much easier to understand than anything these people write in their own defense.

There is nothing wrong with this group per se, and they will tell you that.  The insistence on accepting the Church's teaching on chastity is their standard claim to orthodoxy.  Chastity is after all, what the Catholic Church calls everyone to - according to one's state in life.  Chastity is more than simply abstinence from sexual behavior - but that's another post.  It is clear their network is very tight, perhaps exclusive, a safe distance above theological scrutiny, until now.  The Crisis series is a very good exposé  if you will, bringing to light the confusion generated by this movement.

Like I said, I do believe they are faithful to Church teaching as regards chastity, but what seems in process of developing is a promotion the so-called gay lifestyle - more or less inadvertently perhaps - by advocating queer theory, gender confusion, as well as the idea that God created some persons gay.  In other words, they are saying homosexuality is a good in itself, that it is a gift from God.  This is where they come very close to rejecting magisterial teaching regarding the very nature of man.  I wholeheartedly agree with Mattson and Ruse in calling for their positions to be examined by Catholic theologians.  The articles in Crisis magazine, and the debate these essays generate will hopefully bring about such an examination.

"It must certainly be admitted that man always exists in a particular culture, but it must also be admitted that man is not exhaustively defined by that same culture." - Veritatis Splendor


Sunday, May 20, 2012

This is very good...



What Radical Gays Really Want. - Bonchamps
Since “gay marriage” is all the rage, especially since Biden and Obama decided to make public statements on the matter, it is virtually all I have been hearing about in my own online networks. Debates are raging, friendships are being tested, hostility is everywhere. One thing emerges out of this chaos more clearly than anything else: the gay agenda, which I define as a radical political program with the aim of legitimizing homosexuality in all spheres of human existence, is based on the hysterical repetition of outrageous lies. It is not unlike the completely fraudulent “war on women”, a war that was supposedly declared when a number of Americans publicly resisted the idea that they ought to pay for other women’s birth control.

In the case of “gay marriage”, the big lie is that there is some desire on the part of conservatives and Christians in this country to actually deny some right, some liberty, some freedom to people who identify themselves and live as homosexuals. As abhorrent, disordered and immoral as I find the “gay lifestyle” to be, the truth is that – and here I speak for virtually every conservative Christian I know or have read – we really are not the least bit interested in micro-managing the sex-lives of our fellow citizens. We have absolutely no desire to have uniformed gendarmes kick in your bedroom doors to make sure no acts of sodomy are taking place in the middle of the night. The only thing more repugnant to me than such acts would be the prospect of becoming comfortable with the sort of routine invasions of personal privacy that would be required to ensure that no one was living out their life as a homosexual.

To reiterate, this time specifically to the radical homosexual: on all the issues that concern the consenting adults only, we don’t care. Of course we care in the abstract that you are leading lives of grave sin in open defiance of God, but then so do millions of “heterosexuals” who fornicate, commit adultery, use artificial contraception, sterilize themselves, and so on. Not every sin can or should be a matter for the state to concern itself with, and we are content to let God judge in these matters; but no sin, and this brings us closer to the main point here, can ever be called a virtue, no evil can ever be called a good, by any Christian with a conscience, or by any citizen who cares about the integrity of society. - Bonchamps
It is a long, beautifully written, articulate post - and I completely agree.  I believe it is just the right attitude.  Mark Shea links to the piece as well, and also agrees.  I say that because I came across Shea's post first.  Shea highlights a certain point I think is especially important for every one to note,  Bonchamps makes that point here:
You can live as you want, engage in whatever sort of contracts you like, conduct any sort of ceremonies you please. But there is one thing you cannot have, and it is the one thing you seek through this radical political agenda, these hysterical protests and complaints about Christians: our approval. - Bonchamps
That's it!  Approval.  Not just tolerance.  Not simply acceptance.  But full-blown approval.  The agenda is all about approval - and it is exactly that which the Christian can never give.  There may come a time when the approval is forcibly demanded - thus it is important for the Christian to understand, such approval is not theirs to give.

From Mark Shea:
Yep. That’s exactly what this is about: Narcissism (and homosexuality and narcissism are like peas and carrots) rankles under the awareness of the immovable disapproval of those who know that homosex is disordered and who know what marriage actually is. The hope of the radical homosexual is that somehow that approval can be forced. When it becomes clear that it can’t be, and the might of the state is made available to enact vengeance on the intransigent, it will be, unless God somehow intervenes.

And even if persecution and punishment for failure to approve are meted out, the approval will not be given, because homosex is a sin and gay “marriage” is an ontological impossibility and a good number of people will never back down on those facts.

It’s ironic really. The draconian demand for approval that cannot settle for mere tolerance shows that, at some level, that the gay “marriage” movement which holds Christians in such deep contempt hungers–with the hunger of a child eager to hear a word of praise from her Father–to hear praise from exactly the people that movement claims to despise. And above all, it seems to me that this, in turn, demonstrates that such folk hunger to hear a word of love and welcome from God (as do we all).

We Christians, it seems to me, need to find a way to communicate that the homosexual is loved and welcomed by God–just not the sin of homosex. But that requires that both we and they regard them as something more than their appetites and grasp that they are not identical to or co-terminous with those appetites. - Mark Shea
Seeking approval for coming out and then, for coming in.

Both writers say it well and are in agreement with Catholic teaching - it accords with my personal point of view and perception as well.  I would just add another consideration to the discussion.  The seeking for approval doesn't usually automatically dissolve or go away at conversion - not for the ssa any more than it does for the former prostitute, profligate, or prodigal.  It is not uncommon for the recovering ssa person to continue to desire an inordinate degree of approval - only now as a ssa/gay Catholic back in communion with Catholic teaching - still ssa, and sometimes still needy. 

I often bring this subject up in my posts because there is a natural tendency to expect immediate and total acceptance and approval by every one - considering "all heaven rejoices over one repentant sinner."  So it is not unusual for some  converts to continue to want to be the center of attention.  Some may crave the admiration, or approval of fellow Catholics, and some even expect to be regarded as the authority on same sex issues everyone needs to consult.  Some want to be best friends with non-ssa men who just aren't interested in ssa emotional problems and sexual struggles, and frankly, just aren't comfortable with someone who always needs to reference it.  I know some readers will object to what I say here - my apologies - but it is something to watch out for.

"For they all seek their own interests, not those of Jesus Christ." - Philippians 2:21
Whatever gains I had, these I have come to consider a loss because of Christ.  More than that, I consider everything as loss because of the supreme good of knowing Christ Jesus my Lord. For his sake I have accepted the loss of all things and I consider them so much rubbish, that I may gain Christ and be found in him, not having any righteousness of my own based on the law but that which comes through faith in Christ, the righteousness from God, depending on faith to know him and the power of his resurrection and (the) sharing of his sufferings by being conformed to his death, if somehow I may attain the resurrection from the dead. - 3 Philippians 7-11
 Seek your praise from God.

What does the Church teach? Link:

Considerations Regarding Proposals to Give Legal Recognition to Unions between Homosexual Unions, Congegation for the Doctrine of the Faith