Showing posts with label Pastoral care of transgender persons. Show all posts
Showing posts with label Pastoral care of transgender persons. Show all posts

Saturday, June 11, 2016

More things I don't get ...

Freudian pastoral care.


Homo-nuts.

I watched a bit of Fr. Pacwa interviewing the author Robert Reilly whose new book 'draws from from his extensive knowledge of classic political philosophy to outline the full scope of dangers in modern homosexual culture.'
Robert Reilly was Senior Advisor for Information Strategy (2002-2006) for the US Secretary of Defense, after which he taught at National Defense University. He was the director of the Voice of America (2001-2002) and served in the White House as a Special Assistant to the President (1983-1985). A graduate of Georgetown University and the Claremont Graduate University, he writes widely on "war of ideas" issues, foreign policy, and classical music.
Reilly wrote a very informative book titled: Making Gay Okay: How Rationalizing Homosexual Behavior Is Changing Everything.   I didn't read it when it first came out, just excerpts, but I found nothing wrong with the content.  His appearance on EWTN Live was an interview focused upon the newer, revised edition from Ignatius, sporting a new cover.  (Meant to contrast the incredible change in lgbtq politics from the Reagan White House to the Obama White House.)




When I tuned in Reilly was discussing the American Psychiatric Association removing homosexuality from the DSM, saying it was no longer a mental illness.  Most of my readers know all about that and most also understand it remains a controversial topic.  I turned TV off since I was busy in the garden, and I'm not all that interested in gay stuff anymore.  Nevertheless, I was distracted by what I heard.  Fr. Pacwa was very interested in what Reilly had to say and seemed to be delving into the psychiatric issues.

I understand that priests and spiritual directors are interested in the psychological issues involving homosexuality, yet as the Catechism states, "Its psychological genesis remains largely unexplained. Basing itself on Sacred Scripture, which presents homosexual acts as acts of grave depravity" - thus homosexual acts are intrinsically disordered and contrary to natural law and immoral.   Yet the Church acknowledges its 'psychological genesis remains largely unexplained' and addresses it as a moral disorder.  Therefore, on some level it seems to me the psychological diagnosis is not all that important in pastoral care - nor is pastoral an exercise in conversion therapy - making gay people straight.  The Church never says that.  Likewise, the sacrament of penance - confession - is not to be confused with therapy or psychological analysis.

Of course there is nothing wrong about studying its psychological genesis, especially to understand the homosexual person - but to base pastoral care upon its psychological genesis seems to create a huge obstacle for persons who experience homosexual tendencies.  In other words, does that mean they are nuts?

See, that's what gay people think we mean by using that diagnosis.  I know many successful gay people who have stable relationships - though immoral as regards Church teaching.  Yet they have careers, live quiet lives, in some cases, raise families; many are active in the community, some are in politics, others in ministry - yep - priests.  Are they nuts?  Do they need to be segregated, labeled or diagnosed and stigmatized?  If you examine the lives of homosexual individuals perhaps some have problems - depression, bi-polar, emotional issues similar to straight people.  But are they meant to be in a psychological category all by themselves?  Is there a special medication for it?  If you say you have SSA - same sex attraction, but don't act out, does that mean you're totally sane?

I know a guy who tells gay guys he has SSA all of the time?  Is it empathy?  Disinterestedness to talk like that?  Does it mean he's no longer nuts but wants to help the crazy gay guys he meets?

Which makes me wonder about the ex-gays.  Are they no longer nuts?  Because they renounce homosexual acts and behavior, because they get married, are they suddenly no longer nuts?  I know some ex-gays who are pretty nuts and inordinately focused upon all things homosexual - but they are no longer gay and therefore no longer nuts and everything they say is to be believed because they are no longer nuts.

Get it?

I don't.

Early treatment for hysteria in women.


One more for the road ...

Then there is the case of the transgender woman teaching in Catholic school in San Francisco - approved by Archbishop Cordileone.  (Never forget that Cardinal Burke - as Bishop - gave permission for a transgender woman to be a diocesan religious sister.)

So.  Talk about nuts.  There have been people condemned for coming out as gay - even losing their jobs in Catholic schools and institutions - but transgender is okay under special circumstances?

I'm against it.

Designating homos and trans - the entire spectrum of LGBTQ as mentally ill helps anti-gay people - but does nothing to dissuade persons with these inclinations to 'change' their orientation or their behavior.  Dropping statistical facts on how unhealthy and screwed up the lifestyle can be does nothing to dissuade persons from being 'gay'.

Pope Francis not only speaks about the need to 'discern' but also to 'accompany' and help to 'integrate' those who fall short of Christian wholeness-holiness.  I'm not sure how that works, but I don't think pushing the mental illness diagnosis, or death threats from natural causes work all that well.






Tuesday, September 22, 2015

A Discalced Carmelite Nun in Argentina ...

La hermana Mónica Astorga, carmelita descalza 
que vive en Neuquén (Argentina), 
acompaña desde hace diez años a un grupo de travestis y transexuales ...


'If I had not been accepted in Carmel, I would have entered a Refuge (for fallen women) and lived out my days there, unknown and despised among the poor penitents.'
- St.Therese of Lisieux

I thought of that quote from the testimony by Sr. Marie of the Trinity in the canonization process for Therese, while reading about an Argentine nun who ministers to transgender persons and prostitutes.

Sister Monica Astorga, o.c.d.
For the past 10 years, Sister Monica Astorga, a Discalced Carmelite in the central Argentine city of Neuquen, has helped a group of transvestites and transsexuals who decided to give up prostitution and addictions to alcohol and drugs. She has started them on the path of recovery and reintegration into society.
But the work has been full of obstacles, she said. “People asked me why there were transgendered people in church. I told them the Church is for everyone. Who was Jesus with? With sinners. What is important here is that they live in dignity, so they don’t have to sleep on the street in cold temperatures—even below zero. What I offer them is a space for prayer and to find a way to work, and the rest is for the judgment of God, which I know is so merciful.” - Read the rest at Aleteia
It's a very moving account.  Sr. Monica has the permission of her Bishop, and the encouragement of the Pope.  Perhaps like Bl. Teresa of Calcutta, Sr. Monica received a 'call within a call'.  I also think of  St. Simon Salus, who left his desert solitude to live amongst the outcasts, criminals, and whores, to demonstrate the love of God, to be a sort of presence of merciful love amidst the unlovable.  I'm so edified by this story of Sr. Monica.  I'm betting Sr.'s penitents may not always manage to be faithful, nor may they change all that much in appearance, yet the grace of God is available to them and they have found a place in the Church.

We have to make a place for people in the Church - the truth is, there is a place ... a place for all of us.

Christ can do all things if we ask with faith. "O Lord, I want to return to the Church and the sacraments but I don't know how." The Lord finds a way. When I write about two men or two women living together, agreeing to renounce sinful relations and determining to sanctify their lives and return to the Church and the sacraments, I'm saying that Christ can accomplish for them even more than they ask or desire. The Church does not lay burdens too heavy to carry on those who wish to be reconciled. The Church calls homosexuals, transsexuals, prostitutes, sinners to freedom, to chastity, to holiness. The Church does not dictate with whom and where a person must live, the Church doesn't command a person to join this or that group.

Have faith: Ask, seek, knock. It will be opened for you.

"I go to prepare a place for you...
... You know the way that leads to where I go...
... Follow me...
In my Father's house there are many dwelling places."


O Most Holy Trinity! As many times as I breathe, 
as many times as my heart beats, 
as many times as my blood pulsates through my body, 
so many thousand times do I want to glorify Your mercy.

I want to be completely transformed into Your mercy 
and to be Your living reflection, O Lord. 
May the greatest of all divine attributes, 
that of Your unfathomable mercy, 
pass through my heart and soul to my neighbor.

Monday, January 26, 2015

The Pope receives Diego Neria Lejárraga as an invited, private guest. What's wrong with that?

Diego Neria Lejárraga

What's wrong with that?

Nothing at all ... although a couple of Catholic writers seem to be raising a few red flags, stopping short of suggesting something is wrong about it.  This, despite the fact no one knows any details about the personal meeting or what was said - except the Holy Father and his guests.

Did I mention that Diego Neria Lejárraga is a transgender male?

A transgender man from Spain had a private audience with Pope Francis at the Vatican on Saturday. 
Hoy, a newspaper in the Extremadura region of Spain, reported that Diego Neria Lejárraga and his fiancée had a private audience with the pontiff that took place at his official residence.
Neria told Francis in a letter that some of his fellow parishioners at the church he attends in the Spanish city of Plasencia rejected him after he underwent sex-reassignment surgery. He said a priest even called him “the devil’s daughter.”
Francis called Neria on Christmas Eve after receiving his letter.
The private audience took place a month later.
“After hearing him on many occasions, I felt that he would listen to me,” Neria told Hoy in an interview the newspaper published on Sunday. - Source  Original Spanish report here.

So.  Why would the Holy Father reach out to this man?  I think it's obvious - the man felt rejected by the Church.  The Church doesn't know what to do with these people.  Neria reached out, the Holy Father responded.  That is what he does.  Nothing wrong with that.

As bishop of La Crosse Wisconsin, Cardinal Burke permitted a transgendered woman to begin a religious community, or pious association of the faithful. As bishop, Burke said he did so in consultation with the Holy See. A concerned lay woman went over the Burke's head and complained to the Vatican. As a result, the nascent religious community was disbanded.

In a letter, Bishop Burke responded to the complaint, writing:
"With regard to Sister Julie Green, F.S.J., the recognition of the association of the faithful which she and Sister Anne LeBlanc founded was granted only after consultation with the Holy See," he writes. "These are matters which are confidential and do not admit of any further comment.... I can assure you that Sister Julie Green in no way espouses a sex change operation as right or good. In fact, she holds it to be seriously disordered. Therefore, I caution you very much about the rash judgments which you made in your letter to the Apostolic Nuncio." - Source
Today some people dispute the story about Cardinal Burke, nevertheless it is true, local people know many the story well, knowing both the informant as well as the unfortunate victim.

To my knowledge Cardinal Burke has never responded to the story publicly.

I expect the Holy Father is simply trying to respond to a situation as did Cardinal Burke.