Showing posts with label move along nothing to see here. Show all posts
Showing posts with label move along nothing to see here. Show all posts

Monday, June 20, 2016

The Pope's seemingly contradictory statements ...


Archbishop Jorge Bergoglio speaking at a drug rehabilitation center
in the neighborhood of Bajo Flores in Buenos Aires in 2011.


"All things to all men."

St. Paul wrote, perhaps to assure his critics: "To the weak I became weak, to win over the weak. I have become all things to all, to save at least some." 

That is what I think Pope Francis does when making ordinary, down-to-earth, off-the-cuff remarks.  He likes to speak in the ordinary language of ordinary people of the streets.  Sometimes when I read Alfred Delp, or Walter Ciszek, I am reminded of Pope Francis tends to speak from his pastoral experience as an archbishop, one who spent much time with people who were poor, whose circumstances in life distanced them from the Church.  How much he learned on the 'peripheries' seems to me to parallel what so many priests and religious learned in the prison camps of the 20th century.  We see similar experiences in the lives of laity such as Betsy and Corrie Ten Boom, Bl. Franz Jägerstätter, Madeleine Delbrel, Dorothy Day, and so many other saintly figures of the last century.

It's unusual to see a Pope like him in modern times.

So anyway.  I'm no expert to be sure.  I grew up a bastard - or called that, because my mother was a divorced and remarried Catholic to my dad who was raised Lutheran - and destined for hell because he was not Catholic.  So I was told.  My mother's sin maybe added to her craziness and definitely, along with alcohol, fueled their fighting and much more.  It was a turbulent experience, involving prison, mental hospital stays - in those days that was how they treated alcoholism, abuse, and abandonment, near homelessness with eviction after eviction, failed suicides, attempted murder - very screwed up stuff.  Incredibly, my mother insisted upon a Catholic education and that all of her kids receive the sacraments and attend Sunday Mass.  Amazingly, she prayed - a lot - every day.  She just didn't go to Mass - she was too ashamed.

There were 'better' people, better families than us - though living in similar circumstances - poor, unemployed - but not crazy.  They maybe didn't drink or weren't promiscuous, and they were decidedly more responsible.  Though married, it may not have been a sacramental marriage because it was a second marriage.  The family maintained stability, the kids were raised Catholic, the parents were honest and good people.  (I'm thinking of friend's parents I got to know growing up.)  I think these are the types the Holy Father thinks of when he converses about irregular marriages and families.  Often he says he sees more fidelity, more faithfulness in these situations than he did in 'faithful Catholic' marriages.  I understand that.

I don't know the literary term for it - if there is one - because I've noticed I'm beginning to forget such things, but in my opinion, it is not unlike what our Lord would say when he'd remark, 'such faith I have not seen in all of Israel', or illustrate in the parable of the good Samaritan, how the sinner-outcast-untouchable showed compassion for the man left for dead.  I forgot the name of the Orthodox Bishop author who was so popular in the 1970's - in his book - Beginning to Pray he wrote about a prostitute who out of devotion kept an icon with a lamp burning before it - I was always impressed by that story.  Remember one of Francis' favorite films is La Strada, and I think a few other Fellini films which seem to be all about 'street life' - the poor, the sinners, and their devotion and longing for love.


On that day there shall be open to the house of David
and to the inhabitants of Jerusalem,
a fountain to purify from sin and uncleanness.
- Zechariah 13:1


Perhaps we have a Fellini pope?  I like that.  I love him so much, and I love what others see as contradictory messages.  For me it is so fascinating.  Ask yourselves, what is the greatest contradiction in the world?  What is the sign of contradiction which most marks the life of the Christian?

The cross.  Jesus and him crucified.  How many times did he rebuke his disciples - his priests?  He told them they didn't even know of what spirit they are.  He rebuked them for so many things.  Yet when the Holy Father offers a gentle rebuke, many of us get upset, or feel hurt - or imagine he is changing doctrine or abolishing canon law.  That makes me sad.  

I don't see the pope saying people no longer have to be married, or priests are animals, or that second marriages are better.  I see him using anecdotal experience, examples from ordinary life to illustrate how one ought to accompany and minister and be with the outsider, the excommunicated, the people we used to assume were fated for hell - like I was told my dad was.  The Holy Father seems to me to call all of us to respect their dignity and their humanity, without condemnation and lording our 'holiness' over them.  I do not see him asking for a change in doctrine - far from it.

I'm sure no one will pay attention to this, and that's very good.  Pay no attention to me - one who has been steeped in sin since birth.  I have no authority, and to be sure, the pope doesn't need me to defend him.  I just feel badly that so many get upset, come unglued as it were.  

For the most part, these discussions do not concern me - I'm a single, Catholic man.  Never married, never a father, never a priest.  I count for nothing ...


Scene from Nights of Cabiria, Fellini, 1957.

The film is about a prostitute.  
In the scene, Cabiria and friends join a procession to 
a shrine of the Blessed Virgin Mary.  
Cabiria prays tearfully, “Madonna, help me to change my life.”
The next day she said
everything is the same ...

Saturday, February 27, 2016

Things people claim pope's have said...



"Pope John the XXIII opened the Secret of Fatima in 1960 and cried all day."

I've heard that one since at least the very early 1970's.  Mrs. Duffner maybe?

The other one, Pope Paul VI wept on Pentecost Monday, when he realized there was not going to be an Octave of Pentecost any more. A bishop stated it as fact in his memoirs.

Then there is the report of what JPII supposedly said in 1980 at Fulda about the Third Secret of Fatima. It was roundly disputed at the time that he even said it - now it is claimed to be historically accurate. Oddly enough, Bl. John Paul never read the contents of the secret until after the 1981 assassination attempt. Yet the Fulda statement continues to be circulated as true.

More recently there is the 'approval of the Apparitions at Akita'.  The local bishop approved them as worthy of belief, yet there is no evidence Pope Benedict affirmed the veracity of the messages as Cardinal Ratzinger and head of the CDF.

Despite claims that Cardinal Ratzinger gave definitive approval to Akita in 1988, no ecclesiastical decree appears to exist, as certainly would in such a case. However, some individuals, such as former Ambassador of the Phillipines to the Holy See, Mr. Howard Dee, have stated that they were given private assurances by Cardinal Ratzinger of the authenticity of Akita. In any case, in keeping with the current norms, given the absence of a repudiation of Bp. Ito's decision by his successors, or by higher authority, the events of Akita continue to have ecclesiastical approval. - EWTN

No doubt the local bishop approved the apparition, writing:
"I authorize, throughout the entire diocese, the veneration of the Holy Mother of Akita, while awaiting that the Holy See publishes definitive judgment on this matter." - Akita
. . .


The Paul VI approval of contraception for African nuns... another rumor?

No documentary eveidence has ever been found - so far.  Yet the story had legs.  After Pope Francis repeated it, I decided to contact one Congregation of Belgian nuns who worked in Congo.  (The Nun's Story nuns.)  So far they have not replied, and I doubt they will.  My thought in contacting them was founded on the persistent rumor/story that some provision had been made.  Perhaps it was an inner-congregation agreement, a diocesan proposal?  Something presented to the Congregation for Religious which may have been seen  by the Holy Father?  We may never know.

Phyllis Zagano  has done some research on the veracity of the statement, but it appears she has only been able to confirm the threat not only existed, but nuns really had been sexually assaulted:

The pope's comment about those missionary women religious in the former Belgian Congo was real. Within of week of Congo's June 30, 1960, declaration of independence, the army threatened mutiny. Its officers were white Belgians; its enlisted men were black Congolese. Removing the white officers only made matters worse, and within weeks 25,000 Belgians fled the country.
The missionaries -- men and women -- stayed. They were in grave danger, but they stayed to serve the poor.
Here is what the Belgian Government Information Center wrote about some mid-July 1960 attacks: " ... the nuns ... were put in jail ... Negro soldiers attacked one nun and after a fierce struggle, raped her. Later, they attacked the second nun. Two men trampled her under foot." - NCR

 What about what Pope Francis and Fr. Lombardi said?

That is documented.  It's an 'off-the-cathedra' response to journalists.  Though it may be troubling, even confusing, perhaps the Holy See will make a doctrinal clarification, or a retraction. (Remember when JPII was elected?  He told the crowds in the square, "If I make a mistake - you will correct me.")  I'm sure Pope Francis has been informed that people are confused.   The incident may also end up being just one of those things I don't understand?

Again, recalling John Paul II, remember when he kissed the Koran?

I know!  What was that all about?

Thoughts to take away here ...

You will find all that in a manner lost, which you have  placed in men apart from Jesus. - Imitation, Bk. II, Chp. 7:2.You will soon be deceived if you only regard the outward show of men. - Imitation, Bk. II, Chp. 7:3
Never take a man for your example - however holy he may be - for the devil will show you his faults. - John of the Cross 

It is a great wisdom  to know how to be silent and to look at neither the remarks, the deeds, nor the lives of others... -
John of the Cross

Pray for the Holy Father.  Some saints used to offer themselves as victim souls for the Holy Father, offering all their prayers and sufferings for his intentions.

Tuesday, January 12, 2016

Voris is saying 50% of Catholic priests are gay.


Ruggedly handsome.


Just because a priest is fastidious in his decorum...

I think Sr. Jeannine Gramick said the same thing - although she may have put it at 80%.  Voris' breaking news story here.

People say this stuff all of the time, but no one 'comes out' to prove it, or names names.  Everything moves along as it has always been.  It's innuendo, suspicion, conspiracy driven.  I think it's an exaggeration.  I think it's scapegoating.  I think it's a witch hunt.  I think it needlessly scandalizes ordinary Catholics to announce such things without backing them up with hard facts.

Today - what does it even mean?

Same Sex Attracted?  It's an inclination, a temptation.  What if a faithful priest, who loves Christ and loves chastity, simply experiences an attraction - yet is repelled by the very thought and recognizes it would be a sin?   What if everyone else just thinks this or that guy is gay - but he's never even thought about it?

Gay?  No one is 'gay'.  Right?  That's what 'they' say.

Sexually active homosexual?  Not a good fit for priesthood or religious life.

So.  Does Voris mean that 50% of clergy and religious are living in sin?  That they are active homosexuals in relationships with other men, or that they are promiscuous?  Is there some sort of registry for these men which one might consult to verify the stats?  Are there massive percentages of priests dying of AIDS?  Wouldn't that be front page news?

No doubt there are, and have been such men in the clergy.  No doubt there are adulterers and pedophiles as well - but these types of claims go nowhere.  They are meaningless - especially now days - where is the proof?  These stories feed anti-Catholic-anti-clericalism.  Where are the irrefutable stats and facts and confessions?  What about straight priests who fool around?

If the clergy is that corrupt - we'd know.  We knew about the scandals, we know priests can fall from grace - but to condemn 50% of priests and suggest they are destroying the Church is a very grave accusation and a genuine scandal.

Voris can get by on his rugged good looks for only so long.



What?






Sunday, December 13, 2015

“A true legacy of the Second Vatican Council is being fulfilled in the person and pontificate of Pope Francis.” And that, my friendly traditionalist Catholics, is your problem.



The rejection of the Novus Ordo and Vatican II.

Several recent articles from legitimate Catholic news sites, as well as a few of the fringe sites really reminded me of that fact.  It has been going on since Vatican II - the Remnant, descendant from the Wanderer offers documentation in that regard.  The subtle rejection of Vatican II is the thread running through the 'faithful' Catholic traditionalists.  The rejection of the Novus Ordo is what underlies the current rejection of Pope Francis and the bishops in communion with him.

It has been said progressives have rejected the hermeneutic of continuity, yet it is the traditionalist who promote the hermeneutic of rupture in their outright rejection of Vatican II, including the liturgical reforms, or the Novus Ordo, and most significantly, the documents which include Nostra aetate.  I won't spend time discussing this - others more knowledgeable can do that - but ordinary Catholics should be aware of what is going on with these people.  It has been like this since Paul VI.

A comment from Father Paulo Anto Pulikkan to Catholic News Agency reminded me of that:
“A true legacy of the Second Vatican Council is being fulfilled in the person and pontificate of Pope Francis."
As someone who routinely calls for justice and care for those who are poor and marginalized, the Pope and his plea for “a poor Church for the poor” is a concrete fulfillment of what the bishops of the Second Vatican Council asked for, Fr. Pulikkan said.
The underprivileged “was the theme of the council, but this has been recently very clearly stressed by Francis.” 
Fr. Pulikkan, director of the Chair for Christian studies at the University of Calicut in the Indian state of Kerala, was one of the speakers at a Dec. 9-11 conference in Rome on the protagonists of the Second Vatican Council as seen through the archives.
The conference was organized by the Pontifical Committee for Historic Sciences as well as the Pontifical Lateran University's Center for Research and Studies on the Second Vatican Council.
The council, he told CNA, “is the council for the poor,” which can be particularly seen in the pastoral constitution “Gaudium et Spes,” dedicated to the Church in the Modern World.
In the initial draft, “the concern for the poor was neglected,” he said noting that the same held true for the council's fourth session in 1965.
Despite the fact that the session took place right after the 1964 Eucharistic Congress in Bombay, which focused heavily on solidarity with the poor and was attended by many of the councils protagonists, concern for the poor was “totally neglected.” - CNA

How the Pope is following in the footsteps of his predecessors.

I'm not defending the Pope, as I said last week, he doesn't need me to do that.  Nevertheless, the papacy is one of the reason I stay Catholic.  The main reason I'm Catholic is my faith in the Real Presence of Christ in the Eucharist, the sacraments, and the Blessed Virgin Mary, then Pope and the Magisterium.  It's not the particular pope, but the guarantee of the Petrine office.

That said, an article at NCRegister helps demonstrate - for me at least - how the Holy Father is faithfully following in the footsteps of his predecessors.
Safeguarding the environment has been mentioned to some degree in all recent social encyclicals, but successive popes have increasingly waded into the scientific minutiae of the effects of human activity on ecosystems.
1. The environment first took on a more prominent role when Blessed Paul VI warned in his 1971 apostolic letter Octogesima Adveniens of the “tragic consequence” of unchecked human activity and an “ill-considered exploitation of nature.” He later predicted an “ecological catastrophe” caused by the explosive growth of industrial civilization and stressed the urgent need for “a radical change in the conduct of humanity.”
2. Pope St. John Paul was the first pope to call for an ecological conversion and introduced the theme of human ecology. In his first encyclical,Redemptor Hominis, he warned that human beings frequently seem “to see no other meaning in their natural environment than what serves for immediate use and consumption.” He would then go on to address the issue in additional detail in his 1990 World Day of Peace Message, “Peace With God the Creator, Peace With All of Creation.”
3. Benedict XVI expanded further on ecology, introducing an ecology of peace and social ecology. “The book of nature is one and indivisible,” he wrote in his 2009 social encyclical Caritas in Veritate, adding that it encompasses the environment, life, sexuality, the family and social relations. “The deterioration of nature is closely connected to the culture which shapes human coexistence,” he said.
But most significantly, Benedict was the first pope to refer to climate change, mentioning it on seven occasions during his pontificate, the first time in2007. He also became the first pope to wade into the particulars of safeguarding the environment, trumpeting the “immense potential” of solar energy (installing it at the Vatican and signing a U.N. protocol), preserving water systems, “whose stability could be seriously jeopardized by climate change,” and implementing “appropriate policies for the management of forests.” - Pentin, NCRegister
Pentin loses me when he quotes Sirico of the Acton Institute. Yet this part of the article supports my notion, and therefore works for me.

I might be wrong of course.

Ed. note:  I already know what those who disagree with me want to say.  It goes something like this:
Thank you for revealing your dispositions. It's clear you have no clue what's happening in the Church, and that your arguments (such as they are) are ultramontanist papalotry.  I'm sure Pope Francis appreciates your blind (and dumb) loyalty.
 We love you family.

Yup.


Thursday, December 10, 2015

Prayer shaming - never thought of it that way.



Shortly after the San Bernardino shootings, MSM and social media lit up with hit pieces upon those who say, "Our thoughts and prayers are with you."  Calling out such responses as cliche, critics taunt those who say such things with, "Your prayers aren't working - God isn't fixing this."

Catholics, already weary from Papal shaming they claim is coming from Pope Francis, rushed to the defense of prayer and railed against the bloodless persecution of 'prayer shaming'.  Apparently some sort of action alert went out, and the call was heard by members of the Catholic defenders league and faithful remnant bloggers to defend the practice of prayer.

The criticism isn't new.  Secularists and nonbelievers, along with enemies of religion have always taunted believers.  The psalms are full of laments over it ... My tears have become my bread,by night, by day, as I hear it said all the day long: "Where is your God?"  ... You make us the taunt of our neighbors,the laughing stock of all who are near  ... When I afflict my soul with fasting they make it a taunt against me.  When I put on sackcloth and mourning then they make me a byword,  the gossip of men at the gates, the subject of drunkard's songs.

Nearly every psalm talks about the taunts suffered by the man of God.  Christ himself bore these taunts.  I don't know what Christians expect?  Rewards?  Praise?

We do it to one another as well as to those who are not religious.  How many Christians mocked those who sang John Lennon's "Imagine" after the Paris attacks?  Those who placed flowers and candles and notes?

People mock the Pope and the bishops, as well as the Year of Mercy.  They say the Pope is mean and offers only insults to the faithful.  So many feel abused, and return the abuse, condemning one another.  It's no wonder the world scorns and derides us.

The climate-change in the attitudes of religious people reminds me of growing up in an abusive home; fighting parents, bullying siblings, hostile to religious practice.  As one who grew up in such a hostile environment, and experiencing so much 'shaming' even from people outside the home, I'm kind of accustomed to this sort of treatment.  My sister used to say, 'if God is so good, then why are you so screwed up?'  My mother called me a hypocrite every time I did something wrong, 'you run to church for Mass and come back worse than before.'  My dad and brother were worse.  Even the priests and school sisters were mean and said I prayed too much or was just pretending to pray, or 'you'll never amount to anything.'  LOL!  Sounds like a bad movie, Ive replayed too many times on this blog before - the general conclusion seemed to be: Prayer isn't working - God's not fixing you.

We often tell others the same thing.   People say that to lost causes - like some alcoholic or drug addict who continues to relapse, or a gay person who sees no hope for change, we call them hopeless cases and say, God's not fixing this.

Welcome to the real world.

I probably should have kept my mouth shut.

Oh yes Sister, I know I'll never amount to anything,
my dad already told me that.

Monday, January 28, 2013

Corapi update...



Update on Fr. Corapi – UPDATE | Angelqueen.org 1 day ago – "They say Fr. Corapi lives in a gated community in Whitefish, Montana, on Whitefish Lake. He is seen about riding his Harley." - Google search

There is a discussion at Mark Shea's blog, with links to other stories.  No real news however, but the com box is entertaining.

I had wondered earlier if he might be among those it may have been better if they had never been ordained.  I'll bet he's moved on however, and prefers to be left alone.