Showing posts with label civil unions lead to gay marriage. Show all posts
Showing posts with label civil unions lead to gay marriage. Show all posts

Friday, July 11, 2014

Cardinal Archbishop Rainer Maria Woelki of Berlin takes over Cologne Archdiocese ...

"If two homosexuals take responsibility for each other, 
if they are loyal to each other over the long term,
 then one should see this in the same way as heterosexual relations."


That's it!

I give up.  Why even bother blogging about Catholic teaching any longer?


(Reuters) - The Vatican has appointed the archbishop of Berlin, seen by German media as part of a "new generation" of less dogmatic clergy, to take over the Cologne archdiocese, the largest and richest in Germany, it said on Friday.

The move makes Rainer Maria Woelki, who turns 58 next month, one of the most influential Roman Catholic cardinals and is an indication of the type of person Pope Francis wants to see in prominent Church roles.

Berlin's Tagesspiegel newspaper called him "the prototype of a new generation of bishops ... not grumpy and dogmatic ... these men speak of mercy and mean it. They're open to people, even their critics, to a point and have a heart for the disadvantaged. Still, they're theologically conservative."
In 2012, he said: "If two homosexuals take responsibility for each other, if they are loyal to each other over the long term, then one should see this in the same way as heterosexual relations." - Source


Theologically conservative?


Who am I to judge, huh?

UPDATE:

The Cardinal's statement was clarified/explained back in 2012:
Press Secretary Stefan Förner explained that media reports had severely truncated [the Cardinal's] words. It is the Cardinal’s desire that homosexuals are “not discriminated against.”
The press secretary then explained [the Cardinal's statements] word for word to KATH.NET: “Cardinal Woelki set long-term homosexual relationships in which two people have already made a life-long commitment to one another in relation to [certain] heterosexual relationships which indeed are not in any case “in [proper] Catholic order” (the unmarried, those lacking commitment, etc.). A comparison with sacramental marriage between man and wife was absolutely not the theme.”
Press secretary Förner explained in concluding to KATH.NET: “Sacramental marriage between man and woman retains its special role. I see no cause for confusion.” - American Conservative
Many thanks to a reader who supplied the link.

That about covers it.

ONE MORE UPDATE:

Diane at Te Deum has the last word on this here:  No, Cardinal Woelki didn't say that.  (Part 2)


H/T Creative Minority Report 

Saturday, February 01, 2014

An unfortunate chain of events ...

They're a 'couple'.



"Partners" denied Holy Communion at Mother's funeral: A little bit of history repeating.

Remember the Father Marcel Guarnizo affair a couple of years ago? Fr. Guarnizo denied Communion to a lesbian and her partner because they were a couple - possibly living in sin.  I think one of them was a Buddhist as well as something of an activist - I'm not sure.  Anyway - they were told not to present for Communion, they did and were refused.  Story here.

Just the other day a gay-Catholic left a comment criticizing me for an admonition I wrote as regards SSA Catholics who live together, I had said how it is important for them not to identify or present themselves as a couple.  My critic told me that my statement was nothing more than 'word policing' - that the word has no real meaning, noting:  "besides Marriage itself, the deposit of faith has no category of "couplehood" period."  Ah!  So let's see how that works.  

The gay couple were refused Communion over one word used in an obituary.


A couple who lives outside of Chillicothe say their priest denied them communion when he discovered they were in a same-sex relationship. Carol Parker and her partner of nearly 20 years, Josephine Martin, say they were good standing members of Saint Columban Catholic Church in Chillicothe for 12 years.
They say that all changed when Parker had her mother’s funeral at the church following her death on December 26th. The obituary noted Parker’s mother was survived by a son, a daughter and her daughter’s partner.
“If that one word had not been in there, he would be fine,” said Martin.
Parker said she had been a member since 2001 and served as a lector, a cantor and also sang in the choir. - Story

After the funeral the priest sent a letter to Ms. Parker explaining the teaching of the Church.  It said nothing about 'couplehood' or partnership - yet the use of that one word 'partner' was enough for the priest who explained:  “having a same-sex attraction is not sinful in and of itself … it is only when a person moves from attraction to willfully acting upon it that the situation becomes a sinful matter.”

From the looks of these women I would imagine they are probably not sexually active.  Ordinarily two women or two men, close friends, sharing a house is perfectly fine.  No sin or scandal in that.  Yet when the obituary describes the survivors in what can be interpreted as a same sex relationship or marriage, then that public declaration becomes a problem.  As the minister of the Eucharist, the priest calls the shots.

Likewise, as in the Guarnizo situation, it appears one of the women may dissent on Catholic moral teaching.  Commenting on the priest's actions, she said:
... she hopes that the priest might “open his eyes and fully receive the LGBT community into the church.”

What an unfortunate series of events, huh?  Yet words have meaning - and consequences.

The awful truth.

When Pope Francis said 'who am I to judge' he first noted that he hadn't seen any gay-identity-card-carrying people in the Vatican - in other words, no one was coming up to him and saying "I'm gay.  I'm out.  I want to change/undermine the rules."  He wasn't identifying people by their sexual inclinations.  He went on to explain, "If a gay person seeks God ... who am I to judge."  However, truth be told, if a gay couple comes out and declares they are gay, living as a married couple, then it appears there really is something to judge.  





“I didn't realize this was a sad occasion.” 


Saturday, August 24, 2013

Joseph Bottum.



Bottum.  Joseph Bottum ...

A conservative Catholic now backs gay marriage.  Why?  How?  Evolved?  Huh?

Mr. Bottum’s change of heart is noteworthy. He makes several arguments. The first is pragmatic.  
Basic democratic premises like fairness, equal rights and majority rule suggest that the time for same-sex marriage has come, he says. We can agree, Mr. Bottum argues, that Americans are turning in favor of same-sex marriage, and there “is no coherent jurisprudential against it — no principled legal view that can resist it.” Furthermore, the bishops’ campaigns against same-sex marriage “are hurting the church.” Especially for the young, Catholicism is coming to symbolize repression.  
So this fight would only be worth fighting, for Catholics, if their theology required such a fight. Mr. Bottum now believes — here’s where the essay will really outrage fellow churchmen — that Catholics are mistaken to think that natural law requires them to oppose same-sex marriage. - NYTimes

It's the second time in a day that I've come across gay rejection of natural law... looks like a trend.

Anyway - there will be more defections, mark my words.  It's part of the "gay Christian renaissance".  You'll see.

Monday, July 22, 2013

The Heard Mentality



Gay-Catholic John Heard capitulates ...*
"After many long years of discussion and consideration, and whereas I previously held a different view, it is important now to state clearly that I no longer oppose efforts to reform the [Australian] Marriage Act 1961 (Cth) to provide for same sex civil marriage. I have always believed in the value of marriage and family and I have come to believe that the benefits and rigours of civil marriage and adoption should be extended to same sex attracted men and women.

Inasmuch as some organisations and individuals continue to refer to my previous statements on this matter, and some persist in doing so despite written clarification from me, I now reiterate publicly what I have communicated privately. No one should use my name, image, or previous statements to promote an anti-reform campaign or agenda.

I acknowledge with gratitude those interlocutors over the years who challenged me to reconsider civil marriage reform." – John Heard

What did I tell you?

Song for this post here.

*Available for speaking engagements at your parish or religious education conference!


Acknowledgment to  Wild Reed for the JH quote.