Getting a grip.
.
The brouhaha over what the pope really said in the Peter Seewald interview sent me back to my copy of Salt of the Earth - thanks to Michael R., a conscientious objector and commenter on this blog from time to time, who reminded me about the earlier interview. I spent some time this morning re-reading points I checked earlier - taking time to meditate if you will, what was being discussed.
.
I'm just a student as it were, a learner. I was reminded of this when I came across a response by then Cardinal Ratzinger at the beginning of Seewald's interview. Seewald asked Cardinal Ratzinger about his 'private' opinion on cases before the CDF - if he exercised it in discussions and debates - as if the Prefect had the power to dictate the teaching of the Church - imposing his private opinion, etc.. (It is my understanding decisions are arrived at when consultors are in 'substantial agreement' and implemented after approval by the pope.) But I digress.
.
What impressed me is how Ratzinger responded to the question regarding his private opinion - it is quite humbling to consider, coming from such a learned and brilliant scholar:
.
"[...] I worked for many years as a professor, and I still try my best to keep up with the theological discussion. Naturally I have my own ideas about how theology should look; I also express them in my own publications." - Salt of the Earth; Words and Signs
.
As for me, it is all too convenient to have my own ideas and express them in my
own publications (blog), but how much do I know so much? To whom am I accountable? A man without training and even without access to consultation with expert consultors. At one point in the interview discussing the apparent slowness of the Vatican, the Cardinal points out that some questions resolve themselves in time without intervention. Yet
I want everything to be reformed and settled over night.
.
Asked if the Cardinal would have to contradict himself on occasion, Ratzinger responded:
.
"Let's put it this way: time can certainly bring correction. I can simply learn through dialogue that I haven't seen this or that matter properly. [...] A development through further learning that also brings a correction of past views is entirely within the realm of possibility." Salt of the Earth; Words and Signs
.
And?
.
So what's my point? As a blogger I need to be open to correction and contradiction of my ideas - especially when it emanates from a critical spirit. Hence what appears to be my own backtracking on certain matters is usually a development of learning. As I always say and everyone must understand, I'm no authority.
.
That said, I thought of Chris West and all of the criticism he has undergone after I came across another reply by Cardinal Ratzinger to a question regarding young priests in youth ministry:
.\
"This means that young priests out in the youth ministry who in part have problems proclaiming the sexual morality of the Church as they are supposed to be can be forgiven if on occasion they say something that you don't like?
.
Yes of course, if the basic intention is there. That is the crucial point. No one unfailingly finds the right means at the first go." - Salt of the Earth; The Prefect and His Pope
.
I'm not making any defense or apology for West and the TOB enthusiasts, I'm just saying that though I may take issue with certain points, I'm not competent to critique his entire body of work for instance. The Cardinal (Rigali), bishops and priests and academics who more or less oversee these matters are the competent authority to answer questions and objections regarding the theology of the body.
.
Hopefully, if indeed I continue this blog, I can be less repellent to persons genuinely interested in the faith, the Church, and Catholicism. I'm afraid the critical spirit gets the best of me at times and I frequently fail in charity when discussing contemporary morality and church-people.